Employees Afraid to Discuss Work Toxicity?

by Mar 25, 2026

I just returned from the Ohio Safety Conference (OSC), where I spoke about Why Safety Fails Without Culture & Behavior. In addition to my session, we hosted a booth where we handed out some swag, including copies of my book, Navigating a Toxic Workplace For Dummies.

While we had an overall great experience and tons of wonderful conversations, we noticed something bad happening: People said things like, “Please don’t send me an email-my boss might see it,” or “I can’t take the book because I might get in trouble at work.” 

Unfortunately, this fear isn’t unusual. According to Gallup, only about 3 in 10 employees strongly agree that their opinions count at work, a key indicator of psychological safety.

Millions of employees are navigating workplaces where speaking up or even learning about healthier cultures can feel risky. In this case, even being associated with terms like “toxic culture” or being caught with a book on solving it felt unsafe. (So, sad!)

And that’s a problem. People protect themselves rather than engage, avoid conversations about culture, stop raising concerns and simply disengage or leave.

 

The hidden cost of silence

When employees feel they must hide their interest in workplace civility, the organization pays a price.

First, silence prevents early problem-solving. Issues that could have been addressed through conversation often grow into larger conflicts or turnover.

Second, fear erodes trust. Employees quickly learn that certain topics like bullying, incivility, or toxic behavior are unsafe to discuss.

Finally, disengagement spreads. When people believe nothing will change, they stop trying.

And yet, many leaders never realize this dynamic is happening. After all, if employees are afraid to speak up, leaders may mistakenly assume everything is fine.

 

So what should organizations do?

If employees feel uncomfortable even learning about workplace civility, it’s a signal that psychological safety needs attention. Fortunately, leaders can take concrete steps to change this dynamic.

 

1. Normalize conversations about culture

First, leaders must make discussions about culture visible and routine. When executives openly talk about respect, civility, and psychological safety, it sends a clear message: these topics are not threats. They are priorities.

For example, leaders can regularly ask teams:

  • “What helps you feel respected at work?”
  • “What behaviors make collaboration easier or harder?”
  • “What would make this team even more supportive?”

Over time, these conversations shift culture from silence to openness.

 

2. Examine what behavior is actually rewarded

Most organizations say they value respect and collaboration. However, sometimes there is an overlap between what was said and the definition of what gets rewarded.

If high performers are allowed to behave poorly, employees learn that results matter more than respect.

If people who raise concerns are labeled “difficult,” employees learn that honesty has consequences.

Culture follows incentives. Until behavior expectations apply to everyone, including top performers, employees will remain cautious.

 

3. Close the gap between stated values and lived experience

Most organizations have core values like respect, integrity, and collaboration posted somewhere on their website or office walls

Employees are paying attention to something else: whether those values show up in daily behavior.

If leaders tolerate incivility, ignore bullying, or avoid addressing toxic behavior, the values quickly lose credibility.

And once credibility is lost, employees stop trusting the system to protect them.

 

4. Make learning about culture visible and encouraged

Finally, organizations should actively promote resources that help employees understand healthy workplace dynamics.

That means making conversations about culture visible, normal, and encouraged. Share articles. Host conversations. Offer training. Highlight stories of teams that have improved collaboration or addressed difficult behaviors constructively.

The more visible these efforts are, the less risky they feel. Over time, the message becomes clear: learning about workplace civility isn’t dangerous, it’s expected.

In that spirit, we’re also sharing the resources I offered to attendees at the Ohio Safety Conference, so you have a starting point for conversations within your own organization:

  • How To Measure And Increase Psychological Safety On Your Team
  • Toxic Workplace Risk Management Plan
  • Building a Civil Workplace: An Operational Readiness Check
  • How To Measure And Increase Psychological Safety On Your Team
  • Abrasive Leader Assessment
  • Core Competency Matrix

Get them here.

 

Turning awareness into action

Creating a workplace where employees feel safe to speak up doesn’t happen by accident, it takes intention, leadership, and the right tools.

If you’d like to bring this training to your workforce or explore how to strengthen civility and psychological safety in your organization, connect with us at Civility Partners. We’re here to support you every step of the way.

 

I was honored to be a guest on the Work for Humans podcast with Dart Lindsley, who leads Global Process Excellence for People Operations at Google. His podcast features incredible guests, including Adam Grant.

Dart was one of the most thoughtful and challenging hosts I’ve had the chance to talk with. He asked deeper questions about things like employer abandonment and how organizations can help broker empathy. Check it out!

Incivility, bullying, and harassment occur because the culture allows them to. Before starting inclusivity initiatives, you’ve got to stop bad behavior. Take this assessment to determine if your workplace fosters a positive culture.

 

Catherine

About Catherine Mattice

Catherine Mattice, MA, SPHR, SHRM-SCP, is the founder/CEO of Civility Partners, an organizational development firm focused on helping organizations create respectful workplace cultures and specializing in turning around toxic cultures. Civility Partners’ clients range from Fortune 500s to small businesses across many industries. Catherine is a TEDx speaker and an HR thought leader who has appeared in such venues as USA Today, Bloomberg, CNN, NPR, and many other national news outlets as an expert. She’s an award-winning speaker, author, and blogger and has 60+ courses reaching global audiences on LinkedIn Learning. Her fourth book, Navigating Toxic Work Environments For Dummies (Wiley), is available in all major bookstores and where audiobooks are sold.

10 Thoughtful Finds for Your Team This November

November is when companies start saying “we appreciate you” a little louder. Sometimes that comes with a thoughtful gesture. Sometimes it comes with a branded pen and another urgent assignment. If you’re looking for something your team will actually enjoy, start with...

My Director of Operations Can Be Your Director of Operations

Since I often hear from my audience and followers that they wish they could come work for me, I’m giving you the next best thing—my most trusted team member. It is with a whole lot of bittersweetness that I’m sharing this with you: Rebecca Del Secco, who has been with...

Is Training Enough? 6 Signs Your Company Needs Culture Consulting

Your company invested in training. Employees attended the workshop, passed the quiz, and checked every box. Yet a few weeks later, managers are still dodging difficult conversations, departments are still pointing fingers, and good employees are still heading for the...

4 Ways HR and Leaders Can Address Political Tension at Work

Your employees may disagree about politics. They still need to finish a project together by Thursday. And with the November 3 midterm elections just days away, now is a good time to prepare for the conversations that could follow your employees into meetings, group...

How to De-Escalate Tense Conversations at Work: The 3-Step ART Method for Leaders

Is there a conversation on your calendar this week you’re not looking forward to? Maybe you need to address someone’s behavior, explain an unpopular decision, or sit down with two employees who have apparently decided that making each other miserable is now part of...

5 Best Culture Consulting Firms to Consider and How to Choose the Right Partner

Your company values say “respect.” Your employees would like to know when that takes effect. A company can offer impressive benefits, display inspirational slogans, and call its people its greatest asset while tolerating behavior that sends those same people straight...

Your Employees Aren’t Resistant to Change. Here Are 5 Things They Need to Navigate It

When employees struggle with change, organizations love to reach for a convenient diagnosis: They’re resistant… or they don’t want to learn the new system, they aren’t embracing the new strategy, they keep asking questions leadership thought they already answered, or...

Gallup 2026: Disengagement Hits COVID Levels & What to Do About It

According to Gallup’s 2026 Report, global levels of engagement now match the level we hit in 2020, when only 20% of the global workforce was engaged at work. And that drop “cost the world economy approximately $10 trillion in lost productivity, or 9% of GDP.” Gallup...

3 Reasons Gen Z Is Ghosting Employers and How to Fix It

Search “Gen Z in the workplace” and you’ll find plenty of complaints. You’ll find results like, "They're entitled," "They don’t want to work," "They quit too quickly," "They won’t pick up the phone," and “They accept interviews and don’t show up." Some even accept job...

Do You Want to Share Your Expertise With Civility Partners’ Audience?

Do you have a perspective, idea, or area of expertise that HR professionals and leaders need to hear? We’re opening guest opportunities for professionals who can bring fresh thinking and practical value to the Civility Partners community. There are two ways to join...