5 Signs of an Unhealthy Work Environment & How to Fix It

by Mar 2, 2023

We hear a lot of various words and phrases being thrown around these days – toxic work environment, unhealthy work environment, lacking psychological safety, and more.

In fact I’m often asked, “What is the definition of a toxic work environment?” 

My response is, “Ask your workforce. Let them help you define what unacceptable versus acceptable behavior is.”

That said, lately I’ve been using the phrase “exclusive behavior” because it highlights that all behavior that makes others feel excluded is inappropriate. It doesn’t have to be toxic or unlawful for it to be addressed by a manager or human resources department. 

While I personally operate in the world of workplace bullying (I’ve been researching, publishing, speaking and coaching on the topic for almost 15 years), a lot of behaviors can be considered toxic, exclusive, unhealthy… whatever you want to call it. 

 

Behaviors that Create an Unhealthy, or Exclusive, Work Environment

Someone who frequently interrupts, is constantly negative, acts helpless, is defensive, is chronically late, is unable to read nonverbal cues suggesting you need space, or is passive-aggressive likely falls under the category of someone who exhibits unhealthy behaviors.

These behaviors are also exclusive, in that interrupting someone excludes them from the conversation, and showing up late to their meeting certainly doesn’t show them you respect them. 

I tend to find there are four categories of unhealthy behaviors at work:

  1. Downer behaviors – complaining, critiquing, impossible to please, defensiveness
  2. Better than behaviors – one-upping, name dropping, constantly comparing to others, showing off, grandstanding, humiliating others
  3. Passive behaviors – not providing opinions or suggestions, time sucking, waffling on decisions, helpless, not being direct/talking around sensitive issues
  4. Aggressive behaviors – explosive, bossy, controlling, emotional, passive aggressive, stubborn, abrasive

 

5 Warning Signs of an Unhealthy Work Environment 

While the behaviors above can be observed when someone is paying attention, that requires your managers to be trained in this skill and empowered to address the behaviors when they happen. I know from experience that this type of training is fairly non-existent (unless you’re working with us, of course), so you may need some additional tools to get a sense for your work environment and whether it is healthy and inclusive or unhealthy and toxic. 

 

1. Observable behavior demonstrates a lack of collaboration.

Observe your team – Do they tend to operate in isolation, or perhaps one person isolates themselves? Do they laugh and appear to enjoy each others’ company? Are their nonverbal behaviors indicative of being open and comfortable with each other or closed off and lacking trust? 

 

2. Data shows high absenteeism and turnover.

Surely you can run reports wherever you store your employee data and determine if one particular site or department has higher absenteeism or turnover than others, an indication that it could be unhealthy there. You might also look at productivity, and whether employees are working slower, making more mistakes, or delivering services or goods that are less than quality. 

 

3. Silence or exclusive behaviors during meetings or training sessions.

As trainers, we often observe things that indicate a lack of psychological safety, or the presence of unhealthy behaviors, during training sessions. For example, we may hop around the Zoom breakout rooms to hear what’s happening and will witness people gossiping, making fun of a co-worker, or talking poorly about leadership. We also witness silence, where the lack of participation from the people of color, for example, indicates they aren’t comfortable speaking up. 

 

4. Your organization exhibits risk factors known to foster discrimination, harassment and bullying.

If you check out this page on the EEOC’s website, you can find a nice long list of risk factors. If you have a homogenous workforce, for example, the underrepresented groups can feel isolated while the majority group might feel threatened by the “other” group. Workplaces that value rainmakers is another example, where the rainmaker is allowed to engage in unhealthy behaviors because leaders believe their results outweigh the damage. 

 

5. Your workforce survey data indicates a problem with trust, relationships, or engagement.

While the data may specifically point to low ratings on specific questions, keep in mind that there’s some hidden information too. We recently reviewed a client’s great place to work survey, for example, where approximately half of the survey respondents didn’t indicate their race; the half who did were white. This can indicate a lack of psychological safety around being a person of color in this workplace, something we’re digging into now. 

 

How to Fix an Unhealthy or Toxic Work Environment

As highlighted on our website, the first step is to conduct a survey to uncover the problems and gain clarity on what to focus on.

Be sure to do a climate assessment, which seeks to understand your culture; not to be confused with an engagement survey, which seeks only to measure the level of engagement. We’ve had many clients whose engagement survey scores were great, but when we asked about things like inclusivity, trust in leadership, or effectiveness of communication, the scores pointed to much room for improvement. 

Second, hold a few planning meetings to review the data and develop a clear and tangible action plan for change. When we engage in this process with clients, we end up leading three meetings to get that crystalized plan. The plan should be published to the workforce so they can monitor its progress, and participate where they’d like. 

Third, implement the plan. Now that you have a plan, go for it. Keeping in mind that culture change happens through organizational change and behavior change, your plan will have several action items in both areas.

 

Often, our organizational change plans and projects include things like:

  • Coaching key leaders struggling to adjust their own behavior to meet with the culture vision and core values
  • Revamping the performance management system to gain accountability for the core values and new culture being created and assure a consistent feedback loop
  • Developing career mapping, succession planning programs, and professional growth opportunities for the workforce so that they can see their path inside the organization
  • Creating an employer branding program and/or creating a formal onboarding program that includes orientation to the job and socialization (e.g., buddy system)
  • Conflict mediation between individuals or departments

 

Our behavior change plans (i.e., training programs) often include topics such as:

  • Coming to agreement on values and behaviors as a whole company
  • Adapting values and behaviors across departments and teams
  • Communicating with civility and respect
  • Performance management training
  • Diversity, equity and inclusion topics, including minimizing bias, being an upstander, or helping everyone uncover their own diversity story
  • Proactively building a positive team culture and bringing it to fruition
  • Work-life balance or minimizing stress

 

Incivility, bullying, and harassment occur because the culture allows them to. Before starting inclusivity initiatives, you’ve got to stop bad behavior. Take this assessment to determine if your workplace fosters a positive culture.

 

Catherine

About Catherine Mattice

Catherine Mattice, MA, SPHR, SHRM-SCP, is the founder/CEO of Civility Partners, an organizational development firm focused on helping organizations create respectful workplace cultures and specializing in turning around toxic cultures. Civility Partners’ clients range from Fortune 500s to small businesses across many industries. Catherine is a TEDx speaker and an HR thought leader who has appeared in such venues as USA Today, Bloomberg, CNN, NPR, and many other national news outlets as an expert. She’s an award-winning speaker, author, and blogger and has 60+ courses reaching global audiences on LinkedIn Learning. Her fourth book, Navigating Toxic Work Environments For Dummies (Wiley), is available in all major bookstores and where audiobooks are sold.

Is Training Enough? 6 Signs Your Company Needs Culture Consulting

Your company invested in training. Employees attended the workshop, passed the quiz, and checked every box. Yet a few weeks later, managers are still dodging difficult conversations, departments are still pointing fingers, and good employees are still heading for the...

4 Ways HR and Leaders Can Address Political Tension at Work

Your employees may disagree about politics. They still need to finish a project together by Thursday. And with the November 3 midterm elections just days away, now is a good time to prepare for the conversations that could follow your employees into meetings, group...

How to De-Escalate Tense Conversations at Work: The 3-Step ART Method for Leaders

Is there a conversation on your calendar this week you’re not looking forward to? Maybe you need to address someone’s behavior, explain an unpopular decision, or sit down with two employees who have apparently decided that making each other miserable is now part of...

5 Best Culture Consulting Firms to Consider and How to Choose the Right Partner

Your company values say “respect.” Your employees would like to know when that takes effect. A company can offer impressive benefits, display inspirational slogans, and call its people its greatest asset while tolerating behavior that sends those same people straight...

Your Employees Aren’t Resistant to Change. Here Are 5 Things They Need to Navigate It

When employees struggle with change, organizations love to reach for a convenient diagnosis: They’re resistant… or they don’t want to learn the new system, they aren’t embracing the new strategy, they keep asking questions leadership thought they already answered, or...

Gallup 2026: Disengagement Hits COVID Levels & What to Do About It

According to Gallup’s 2026 Report, global levels of engagement now match the level we hit in 2020, when only 20% of the global workforce was engaged at work. And that drop “cost the world economy approximately $10 trillion in lost productivity, or 9% of GDP.” Gallup...

3 Reasons Gen Z Is Ghosting Employers and How to Fix It

Search “Gen Z in the workplace” and you’ll find plenty of complaints. You’ll find results like, "They're entitled," "They don’t want to work," "They quit too quickly," "They won’t pick up the phone," and “They accept interviews and don’t show up." Some even accept job...

Do You Want to Share Your Expertise With Civility Partners’ Audience?

Do you have a perspective, idea, or area of expertise that HR professionals and leaders need to hear? We’re opening guest opportunities for professionals who can bring fresh thinking and practical value to the Civility Partners community. There are two ways to join...

AI Could Kill Humans in the Next Decade?? Leaders, Here Are 4 Things You Can Do Now

There are headlines you read, shake your head at, and move on from. Then there are headlines like this one: AI could kill all humans within the next decade. It sounds like the plot of a sci-fi movie. Some of the people raising these concerns are building the...

Why Are People So Sensitive? 4 Things Have Changed at Work

“Why is everyone so sensitive these days?” I hear some version of this all the time. Employees are offended by everything. Managers can’t say anything anymore. People need constant reassurance. Nobody can take a joke. Everyone has to walk on eggshells. And usually,...