5 Unfair and Discriminatory Hiring Practices That Go Unnoticed

by Apr 3, 2024

Written by: Cleo Tubon and Jennifer Areola

Businesses that prioritize diversity in their workforce significantly increase the likelihood of fostering creative and innovative thinking among their employees by 150%. Also, companies with a lot of different ethnicities and races in their management team are 35% more likely to do better than average in their industry. 

For a long time, people have understood that teams with diverse backgrounds work better together. How can you make sure your workplace is diverse? One way to do this is to eliminate discrimination. 

 

So, what is hiring discrimination?

Hiring discrimination occurs when unfair hiring choices are made based on factors like a person’s color, religion, sexual orientation, place of origin, age, or genetics. Disability discrimination and racial bias are also forms of discriminatory practices in hiring.

Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 provides that it’s unlawful to:

(1) Refusing to hire or firing someone, or treating them unfairly in terms of pay, conditions, or benefits because of their race, color, religion, sex, or national origin is prohibited.

(2) Segregating or categorizing employees or job applicants in a way that denies them employment opportunities or negatively impacts their status as an employee based on their race, color, religion, sex, or national origin is also not allowed.

 

Unfair and Discriminatory Hiring Practices That Go Unnoticed

When it comes to hiring new employees, ensuring fairness should be at the forefront of every employer’s mind. Unfortunately, some unfair practices can slip under the radar, creating unnecessary hurdles for certain groups of people. Let’s take a closer look at five of these hidden biases that can affect hiring decisions:

 

1. Discrimination Based on Sexual Orientation or Gender Identity

Going into a job interview excited about the opportunity but only to face biased questions or even harassment because of who you love or how you identify is a reality for many individuals. And let’s not forget about gender discrimination, where women still face unequal treatment and lower pay compared to men, despite their qualifications.

 

2. Unconscious Bias in Resume Screening

Recruiters may unknowingly exhibit bias when reviewing resumes. Research shows that names, alma maters, or extracurricular activities can trigger implicit biases, favoring certain demographics over others. This can result in qualified candidates being overlooked based on non-essential factors.

 

3. Nepotism

It’s disheartening when you realize that a job might not go to the most qualified person but rather to someone with a personal connection. Nepotism shuts out talented individuals who could bring fresh perspectives and skills to the table, all because they don’t have the right connections.

 

4. Racial Discrimination

According to HBR, underrepresented individuals who whiten job resumes get more interviews. Despite the progress we’ve made, racial discrimination still lingers in hiring practices. People of color often find themselves facing unfair treatment during interviews, encountering biased decisions and facing systemic barriers that limit their opportunities.

 

5. Salary History Inquiries

While asking about previous salaries in a job interview may seem harmless, it actually perpetuates wage disparities, especially for underrepresented groups. This practice can lock individuals into lower salary brackets, regardless of their qualifications or the value they bring to the role, further widening the wage gap and hindering efforts to achieve pay equity. 

 

Of course, these are not all. Factors like age, disability, exclusive job ads, and more can also influence hiring decisions unfairly. It’s essential to shed light on these issues. Employers need to actively acknowledge and address these biases to ensure that every candidate has a fair shot at employment. 

Addressing these hidden biases requires a proactive approach from companies. Implementing structured hiring processes, providing bias awareness training to recruiters and interviewers, and diversifying hiring panels are crucial steps toward fostering equitable and inclusive workplaces.

We specialize in creating custom training programs tailored to your company’s needs from your leadership team to your entire workforce. Our training includes scenarios relevant to your workforce and incorporates your organization’s vision, mission, and core values to strengthen your company’s culture. 

Also, we are offering our Practicing Fairness as a Manager course for FREE! 

PS.

Join Catherine tomorrow for an engaging 30-minute LinkedIn Live Show all about “Inclusivity Throughout the Employee Life-Cycle!” Don’t miss out on this SHRM-credited webinar packed with valuable insights! Secure your spot now. We’re bringing you these insightful sessions monthly—so follow Catherine on LinkedIn for all the latest updates! (But we’ll still keep you posted here too!) See you there! 

When it comes to DEI, language matters…and it’s constantly evolving. Are you using the right terminology in your organization? Download our DEI Terminology Cheat Sheet and see how you stack up.

 

About Catherine Mattice

Catherine Mattice, MA, SPHR, SHRM-SCP is President of consulting and training firm, Civility Partners, and has been successfully providing programs in workplace bullying and building positive workplaces since 2007. Her clients include Fortune 500’s, the military, several universities and hospitals, government agencies, small businesses and nonprofits. She has published in a variety of trade magazines and has appeared several times on NPR, FOX, NBC, and ABC as an expert, as well as in USA Today, Inc Magazine, Huffington Post, Entrepreneur Magazine, and more. Catherine is Past-President of the Association for Talent Development (ATD), San Diego Chapter and teaches at National University. In his book foreword, Ken Blanchard called her book, BACK OFF! Your Kick-Ass Guide to Ending Bullying at Work, “the most comprehensive and valuable handbook on the topic.” She recently released a second book entitled, SEEKING CIVILITY: How Leaders, Managers and HR Can Create a Workplace Free of Bullying.

It’s Labor Day: Are you celebrating your workers or burning them out?

This last Labor Day should have been a day of rest—a chance for employees to recharge and reflect on the contributions they’ve made to their organizations. But for many workers, the reality was likely far from relaxing. A 2023 Gallup survey shows that only 32% of U.S....

Case Study: HR’s Pleas Are Heard, Resulting in Positive Culture Change

HR professionals often find themselves fighting an uphill battle to create a positive and safe workplace. Not to rub it in, but we thought we’d share a case study of what could be when the opposite occurs. Read on and see what happens when leadership listens to HR, as...

FREE WEBINAR: Getting Leadership to Listen to HR

Do you ever feel like you're pouring your heart into your work, only to have it go unnoticed?  As an HR professional, you’re tasked with and excited about creating a positive workplace, solving complex issues, creating and implementing strategies, and driving...

Out of Sight, Not Out of Mind: Employee Disengagement in Remote Work (And 5 Strategies to Overcome it)

Remote work is here to stay and has completely changed how we do our jobs. While offering the flexibility and convenience that many employees love, it also brings its challenges. One of the biggest could be employee disengagement.  Since this is a hot topic online, we...

Make a Positive Impact & Earn $ With Civility Partners

You read our blog every week because you care about an inclusive work environment for all individuals at all levels. Either you consult in a similar space, or want to have an impact on your own workplace. For the past 15 years, Civility Partners has been on a mission...

How to Coach Abrasive, or Bullying Leaders

Consider that abrasive leaders, or workplace bullies, engage in aggressive behavior mainly because they’ve been allowed to by their own boss, even encouraged to through promotions, accolades and increased pay.  Their high value to the organization (e.g., sales,...

MIT, Glassdoor, and Deloitte all say people care more about culture than pay: Why aren’t you focused on culture?

Research everywhere speaks volumes. It consistently highlights a significant shift: People care more about workplace culture than their salaries. So, why aren't more companies prioritizing workplace culture?   The Disconnect: Why Culture Gets Overlooked Here are...

3 Reasons Your Hiring Process is Too Lengthy and How to Fix it

Hiring the right person is essential, but a drawn-out hiring process can harm your organization more than you might realize. Missed opportunities, decreased productivity, and losing top candidates to competitors are just a few of the costly consequences. While being...

5 Skills Your Managers Need (But Probably Don’t Have) to Effectively Interview Job Applicants

Did you know that 76% of hiring managers admit that attracting the right job candidates is their greatest challenge? Why? Because many managers lack key skills needed for effective interviewing. Culture matters to employees, but it’s just as crucial for hiring. Keep...

Concerned about discussions of opposing political views at work?

Election season is here, bringing with it a flood of discussions, debates, and distractions. Add global tensions dominating the news, and it's easy to see why employees might struggle to stay focused… especially if they have opposing views from their colleagues… and...