A Hiring Horror Story

by Oct 30, 2018Uncategorized0 comments

Last Friday during a “get to know you” coffee, a local business owner shared his Hiring Horror Story.

After countless hours recruiting, sifting through resumes, phone screening and interviewing he had his candidate. The resume sparkled with the perfect experience, and the candidate rocked each interview.

The candidate started on a Thursday and wouldn’t you know it… was screaming at him the very next Monday! Yep, she screamed at him. At work. On day three of employment.


Here are some tips in three important areas, to ensure you don’t run into the same problem:


Interviewing is a skill. There’s a reason the staffing industry was an estimated $461 billion dollar global industry in 2017. This doesn’t even account for the billions companies spend on in-house/corporate recruiters.

Day in and day out, recruiters hone their craft learning not only what to ask but how to ask it so a candidate will respond in a manner that provides meaningful insight… and they can still get it wrong.

Tip: Coach your hiring managers on how to interview to match for management styles, work behaviors, and team culture. If you don’t have the luxury of a supportive HR team, then learn about interview techniques, leverage HR folks in your network or even ask a professional recruiter to sit in on your top interview(s).

Reference Checks

Yes, some references inevitably are friends providing fluff but that doesn’t negate the value of checking references. Understanding the strengths, weaknesses, passions and pitfalls of your candidate, even the fact that they can only provide friends as references, is valuable insight.

You never know what you’ll get; I’ve had a candidate put a prior employer they stole from as a personal reference. They later admitted it wasn’t their brightest idea, and I learned not to hire them.

Tip: Provide context and be unique in the initial and follow up questions you ask. “We like to support everyone for success. Tell me more about their growth opportunities,” goes a lot further than the tired “What are their weaknesses?” You’ll be shocked at how much someone’s friend shares when they are “helping”.

Background Checks

According to the FBI nearly 73.5 million Americans have a criminal record. That’s nearly 30% of the adult population; 1 in 3 adults!

Understand that a criminal record does not mean someone is a bad employee. It is extremely important that we as a society work to reintegrate folks and support them in being productive members. I mention the high rate of criminal records in adults to emphasize the need to understand the risks associated with a given role and whether or not a candidate is prone to unacceptable behaviors increasing that risk.

Tip: Do a comprehensive and thorough (all court systems, past residences & alias names) background check that screens for threats related to the role and company as a whole. Individually assess each candidate against what is an acceptable level of risk for that role. It is important to note that some jurisdictions (LA, NYC, etc.) have additional assessment requirements; check with your employment attorney.


So, what about the screaming employee?

Sure, there’s no guarantee this screamer would not have slipped through had my coffee buddy followed the above steps. However the likelihood would have been dramatically reduced for a nominal cost – compared to the mental anguish, lost revenue and productivity, and time spent on this bad hire. Not to mention the stress.


We’ve got an upcoming webinar with more tips for good hiring, background checks, and making sure your compliance efforts are also inline with building a positive environment. Sign up here. You don’t want to miss it!

Chat soon,

Civility Partners’ newest addition, The Prince of Pre-Hire, The Baron of Background Checks, The Oracle of Outsourced HR… or as the team knows me, Nick.

P.S. At the webinar, we’ll also talk about how to use your employer brand to get good people in and keep bad hires out, as well as how to make your background check part of the onboarding/culture-building experience.

About Catherine Mattice Zundel

Catherine Mattice Zundel, MA, SPHR, SHRM-SCP is President of consulting and training firm, Civility Partners, and has been successfully providing programs in workplace bullying and building positive workplaces since 2007. Her clients include Fortune 500’s, the military, several universities and hospitals, government agencies, small businesses and nonprofits. She has published in a variety of trade magazines and has appeared several times on NPR, FOX, NBC, and ABC as an expert, as well as in USA Today, Inc Magazine, Huffington Post, Entrepreneur Magazine, and more. Catherine is Past-President of the Association for Talent Development (ATD), San Diego Chapter and teaches at National University. In his book foreword, Ken Blanchard called her book, BACK OFF! Your Kick-Ass Guide to Ending Bullying at Work, “the most comprehensive and valuable handbook on the topic.” She recently released a second book entitled, SEEKING CIVILITY: How Leaders, Managers and HR Can Create a Workplace Free of Bullying.

5 Department-Specific Digital Tools to Increase Productivity

Workers everywhere are doing their best to adapt to this uncertain and ever-changing world. Some are finding ways to push forward, and others are not so lucky.  Operating a business from home is filled with its own set of stressful challenges: the kids are home,...

Your New Normal Must Include Room for Emotions

During these past few months, we bet employees haven’t been totally honest about how they’re feeling. There are two reasons they’ve been hiding the truth:  First, showing emotion is socially unacceptable at work. It’s considered weak and unprofessional to cry,...

Using Your DISC Profile to Get Back to the Workplace

News is starting to look more positive and hopeful, and talk of reopening is a brewin’. I don’t know about you, but I could use some serious hugs from all of my colleagues!! (Yes, I’m a High I.) We thought a little insight about how DISC profiles play into coming back...

Case Study: 8 Tips for Successfully Converting Classroom to Virtual Training

Recently, I was to attend a two-day consultant’s workshop in New York City put on by David A. Fields. David is a consultant to consultants, and I was excited to sit in a room with other consultants to learn from him and from them.  But, alas, the in-person...

Playlist: 25 Songs for…Well… This

According to this article researchers have found evidence that certain songs will maximize productivity and creativity. I buy it. I think we all know music can affect our mood. Apparently, “songs by Queen, 50 Cent, Kanye West and Coldplay were among those…” most...

5 Tips and 5 Questions: Helping Employees with Stress

This is the week we’re hearing our clients’ employees cry out. The stress of the current situation and the need to wear so many hats at all times is breaking some. Others are already there. Work, homeschooling, meals, groceries, and household stuff are pulling them in...

Parents, You’ve Got This

Something really amazing happened last week. One of my team members has a son, Davis, with quadriplegia and blindness. He was born this way; doctors told his parents to prepare for the worst. Now at age 7, Davis is working hard to overcome all odds. And last week, for...

[Webinar] Using DISC to Increase Civility, Engagement and Personal Leadership

DISC is such a useful tool when it comes to building cohesive, collaborative, civil teams. Check out this hour long webinar on Using DISC to Increase Civility, Engagement and Personal Leadership hosted by our very own Catherine Mattice Zundel and Toni Herndon.

5 Quick Tips You Need Right Now

In case you missed it, we’re running a bi-weekly Mastermind group to provide the opportunity for you to get on the horn and talk to other leaders in your same boat.  Our first call was last week, and we had some great discussion. Several articles and resources...

Former American Apparel CEO: 3 Tips for Leading in a Crisis

Chelsea Grayson is no stranger to crisis. She took over as CEO at American Apparel in the midst of a whopper. Chelsea was general counsel at American Apparel in 2014 when founder/CEO, Dov Charney, was fired from his position for many debacles - including repeated...