How to Coach Abrasive, or Bullying Leaders

by Jul 23, 2024

Consider that abrasive leaders, or workplace bullies, engage in aggressive behavior mainly because they’ve been allowed to by their own boss, even encouraged to through promotions, accolades and increased pay. 

Their high value to the organization (e.g., sales, organizational knowledge, professional network) means leadership works around them or ignores their behavior for fear that addressing it may end poorly. That is, leadership is worried the leader will retaliate with even worse behavior, or quitting and taking all of that high value to a competitor. 

Failing to address the behavior certainly sends the message that it’s okay, and promoting the individual for their results without consideration for how they achieve them further solidifies the bad behavior.

I’ve found over the years in coaching these individuals that, as you’d expect, they lack social and emotional intelligence. What drives their behavior, however, is that they’re seeking to be seen as highly competent and are therefore focused on results and outcomes. They don’t intend to be a bully – they intend to get results – and the lack of social and emotional intelligence means they don’t understand the impact of their behavior. In fact, these leaders care deeply about the success of not only themselves, but their teams and the organization as a whole. 

I’ve also found some other patterns over the years, including that these leaders have often learned to act this way during childhood or from an organization, and that they’ve been fighting to be seen as competent their entire lives. For example, one coaching client came to the US with no money in her pocket and no ability to speak English, and worked her way into a high-powered role in a pharmaceutical company. Another was the only female and only single parent in medical school, fighting to be seen as equal. Yet another had tried to get into the NFL after college but couldn’t, and the failure had clearly stuck with him.

Thankfully, employers can turn the tides and provide the opportunity for improvement via coaching.

 

Before Coaching Commences

It’s natural to avoid having a direct conversation with someone about their abrasive behavior; they’re high-conflict and aggressive, and the fear of them quitting is real. That never actually happens, though.

Instead, employers must set the stage for success by delivering a clear message about the behavior that must change, and expectations for doing so and by when. A consequence must also be in place to demonstrate that change is required. Otherwise the leader assumes this just another request to improve that they can ignore, because there’s never been consequences before.

I suggest employers state that while the consequence is very real, they know it won’t be needed because they believe in the leader’s ability to change. So much so, that they’re going to invest in coaching.

 

Coaching Abrasive Leaders

Now that the leader is fully aware of the reality of the situation, they need to understand how they’re truly perceived so they can change it. Holding up the mirror is a key step in the coaching process, and the process unfolds as follows:

 

1. Collect Feedback

Begin the coaching process by gathering feedback from peers and subordinates identified by both the client and employer. I first obtain the leader’s permission to interview eight to ten people, whom the client then invites to participate in the coaching process. I also get permission to interview three to five coworkers who have confidentially raised concerns with the employer, and ask the employer to invite those individuals to participate in interviews. These “confidential add-ons” provide additional anonymity in the feedback document provided to the leader, and ensure the scope of perceptions collected through interviews is wide.

 

2. Deliver Feedback

After the interviews, anonymize and organize the feedback into themes for the client to review. This feedback, often 15-20 pages long, highlights specific behaviors that generate negative perceptions. The impact of their behavior is no longer hearsay from the boss or HR, who may have asked the leader to be nicer in the past, but without any real examples or consequences to ensure the message got through. The leader is now faced with the decision to own up to the behavior and change, or accept the employer’s consequence.

Clients’ reactions vary from shock and defensiveness to acceptance and sadness. Initially unaware of their impact on others, the feedback can be jolting. Yet, clients are motivated to engage in coaching because they fear incompetence, and the feedback has underscored their incompetent leadership.

 

3. Engage in Coaching

An effective coaching program uses the methods of Dr. Laura Crawshaw, a pioneer in the workplace bullying space. One model she uses is the very simple and instinctual idea of “fight or flight”. This is such an easy way to explain behavior – the abrasive leader’s feedback highlights that they are “fighting”, which means they feel threatened (by incompetence). The feedback also highlights that everyone else is “fleeing” by avoiding the leader, creating special processes to avoid them, and so on.

The goal of coaching is to assist the leader in noticing when people flee or fight, assess why they do that (i.e., what they’re threatened by), and adjust behavior accordingly.

For example, one coaching client said no one speaks up in the Monday morning meetings (i.e., they flee via silence). So I asked, “What are they afraid of?” He suggested that they were lazy, or afraid their ideas weren’t good enough. After pointing to his feedback, which indicated he is argumentative and unable to control his emotions, he determined that people were afraid of him. Now he understands the damage his behavior is causing; the team isn’t incompetent, they’re afraid of him.

 

4. Ensure the Abrasive Leader’s Boss is Checking In

One effective approach is to include coaching the abrasive leader’s boss, because the boss has obviously been “fleeing” the conversations needed for accountability. I hold three coaching sessions with the boss, and require that the boss is checking in regularly with the abrasive leader. This shows the leader that the boss is invested, and willing to step out of their own comfort zone to help the abrasive leader be successful.

 

5. Second Round of Interviews

After three to four months of coaching, a second round of peer interviews assesses progress. The feedback highlights improvements in coworkers’ perceptions and identifies areas needing further focus. As before, interview notes are themed and shared with the client in a document.

 

After Coaching

Employers should continue to check in with the leader and hold them accountable to the expectations set out at the beginning. If needed, remind the leader that the consequence is always on the table. 

Checking in is paramount to success because coaching is only a moment in time focused on teaching new habits. Breaking old habits and engaging in new ones will take time – and accountability. 

 

Abrasive Leaders can Change

Abrasive leaders can change with the right support. Employers must enforce healthy and respectful behavior for everyone, including high performers, to ensure a safe workplace. They need to set limits and consequences for abrasive behavior. Failure to do so signals acceptance of destructive leadership styles, which causes distress in employees and harms retention and reputation. 

 

About the Author

Catherine Mattice, MA, SPHR, SHRM-SCP, is the founder/CEO of Civility Partners, a strategic organizational development firm focused on helping organizations create respectful workplace cultures and specializing in turning around toxic cultures. Civility Partners’ clients range from Fortune 500’s to small businesses across many industries. Catherine is a TEDx speaker and an HR thought-leader who has appeared in such venues as CNN, NPR, and many other national news outlets as an expert. She’s an award-winning speaker, author and blogger, and has 50+ courses reaching global audiences on LinkedIn Learning.

Do you know how much money chronically bad behavior costs your company? Spoiler alert – it’s a LOT higher than you want it to be. Download our data and worksheet to see how it’s costing your organization and what you can do to fix it.

 

About Catherine Mattice

Catherine Mattice, MA, SPHR, SHRM-SCP is President of consulting and training firm, Civility Partners, and has been successfully providing programs in workplace bullying and building positive workplaces since 2007. Her clients include Fortune 500’s, the military, several universities and hospitals, government agencies, small businesses and nonprofits. She has published in a variety of trade magazines and has appeared several times on NPR, FOX, NBC, and ABC as an expert, as well as in USA Today, Inc Magazine, Huffington Post, Entrepreneur Magazine, and more. Catherine is Past-President of the Association for Talent Development (ATD), San Diego Chapter and teaches at National University. In his book foreword, Ken Blanchard called her book, BACK OFF! Your Kick-Ass Guide to Ending Bullying at Work, “the most comprehensive and valuable handbook on the topic.” She recently released a second book entitled, SEEKING CIVILITY: How Leaders, Managers and HR Can Create a Workplace Free of Bullying.

Why leadership’s ‘Hands-Off’ approach to culture is costing you more than you think

Picture this: you’re actively working to foster a positive workplace culture, but managers and leaders are adopting a 'hands-off' approach. At first, it seems harmless, even convenient—but beneath the surface, it's quietly wreaking havoc. Top talent? They're slipping...

Elections and Leadership: 3 Ways Your Reaction Can Impact Your Team

Election season tends to bring division and tension, and it’s hard to avoid. Even if you’ve reminded your team to steer clear of political conversations at work, it’s likely that the topic will still pop up here and there. The truth is, having employees with different...

You Have It All Wrong: 4 Ways Employers Can Successfully Influence Well-Being

Did you know that the World Health Organization (WHO) classified burnout as an occupational phenomenon? In other words, while leaders and HR tend to classify burnout as a personal failing, as evidenced in the way they tackle it with offerings of gym memberships and...

5 Tips You Haven’t Seen for Engaging Hybrid And Remote Workers

According to Forbes, one in five workers is working remotely and 98% of workers want to work remotely at least some of the time. Yet, despite the flexibility that hybrid and remote work offer, engagement is a major challenge. In fact, the 2023 State of Remote Work...

Measuring Onboarding Effectiveness: Key Metrics for Success

Having an employee orientation program is a great start. It usually involves getting paperwork signed, introducing new hires around the office, and providing some initial training. But are you truly onboarding your employees? Effective onboarding is more than just a...

Measuring Recruiting and Hiring Success: Key Metrics to Track

In the past, recruiting was often a "spray and pray" approach—posting job openings everywhere and hoping the right candidate would find their way to us, even faxing over their resumes. Thankfully, recruiting today is far more strategic, thanks to the internet and...

HR Ninja-ing: 9 ways to impact culture with $0 budget

Workplace culture is an uphill battle when the budget is tight or, worse, nonexistent. You’re expected to create a thriving, engaged workforce, but the reality is harsh: Gallup reports that only 32% of U.S. employees are engaged at work. Meanwhile, disengaged...

It’s Labor Day: Are you celebrating your workers or burning them out?

This last Labor Day should have been a day of rest—a chance for employees to recharge and reflect on the contributions they’ve made to their organizations. But for many workers, the reality was likely far from relaxing. A 2023 Gallup survey shows that only 32% of U.S....

Case Study: HR’s Pleas Are Heard, Resulting in Positive Culture Change

HR professionals often find themselves fighting an uphill battle to create a positive and safe workplace. Not to rub it in, but we thought we’d share a case study of what could be when the opposite occurs. Read on and see what happens when leadership listens to HR, as...

FREE WEBINAR: Getting Leadership to Listen to HR

Do you ever feel like you're pouring your heart into your work, only to have it go unnoticed?  As an HR professional, you’re tasked with and excited about creating a positive workplace, solving complex issues, creating and implementing strategies, and driving...